This work presents a new method for enhancing the performance of a dual band Planer Inverted-F Antenna (PIFA) and its lumped equivalent circuit formulation. The performance of a PIFA in terms of return loss, bandwidth, gain, and efficiency is improved with the addition of the proposed open stub in the radiating element of the PIFA without disturbing the operating resonance frequencies of the antenna. In specific cases, various simulated and fabricated PIFA models illustrate that the return loss, bandwidth, gain, and efficiency values of antennas with longer optimum open stub lengths can be enhanced up to 4.6 dB, 17%, 1.8 dBi, and 12.4% respectively, when compared with models that do not have open stubs. The proposed open stub is small and does not interfere with the surrounding active modules; therefore, this method is extremely attractive from a practical implementation point of view. The second presented work is a simple procedure for the development of a lumped equivalent circuit model of a dual band PIFA using the rational approximation of its frequency domain response. In this method, the PIFA’s measured frequency response is approximated to a rational function using a vector fitting technique and then electrical circuit parameters are extracted from it. The measured results show good agreement with the electrical circuit results. A correlation study between circuit elements and physical open stub lengths in various antenna models is also discussed in detail; this information could be useful for the enhancement of the performance of a PIFA as well as for its systematic design. The computed radiated power obtained using the electrical model is in agreement with the radiated power results obtained through the full wave electromagnetic simulations of the antenna models. The presented approach offers the advantage of saving computation time for full wave EM simulations. In addition, the electrical circuit depicting almost perfect characteristics for return loss and radiated power can be shared with antenna users without sharing the actual antenna structure in cases involving confidentiality limitations.
Multiband small-size Planer Inverted-F Antennas (PIFAs) are designed to compensate the reduction in size and space of modern era mobile phones. Modern portable cellular devices also require increased operational bandwidth for the installed antennas, preferably in several bands [1, 2]. Previously, shaping and tilting of the antenna structure was proposed to increase the operational characteristics of multiband antennas [3]. However, modern techniques for enhancement of an antenna’s performance (e.g., VSWR, return loss, etc.) include E-shaped [4] and L-shaped [5] slitting in the antenna structure, using a pin instead of a plate for shortening [6, 7], adjustment of the space between the feed and short [7, 8], matching circuits [9], meandering [10], optimum height of the radiating patch [7], size of the ground plane [6, 7], broadband circular patches [6], and ground plate slotting [11] . The increase in the bandwidth of the antennas is proportional to the antenna volume. Antenna volume is highly dependent upon the radiating element and ground plane as these elements enclose the forming strong electric field area. In [12], the author proposes that antenna volume can be increased by shifting the radiating patch away from the ground plane. The shifting of the radiating element enhances the antenna bandwidth because of reduced ground area [12].
PIFAs are usually installed at the bottom end of a mobile phone to provide the maximum isolation to the data processing module and to control the specific absorption rate (SAR) magnitude. Most modern cell phones have a structure with a bottom interface connector (IC) used for data exchange and power purposes. The IC is located in close proximity to the antenna and its metallic structure causes the degradation of various antenna performance metrics. It particular, it degrades the antenna’s radiation parameters (gain and efficiency), return loss, and bandwidth in lower bands, such as GSM 850 and GSM 900. In this study, a method is proposed for improving dual band PIFA performance using an open stub in the vicinity of the metallic IC. The addition of an open stub away from the ground plane enhances the antenna volume, which results in incremental improvements of various performance metrics. A gradual increase in the length of the introduced open stub in the PIFA radiating structure shows an enhancement of up to 4.6 dB in return loss, 17% in bandwidth, 1.8 dBi in gain, and 12.4% in the efficiency of the antenna. The experimental results of the proposed antenna structure are in good agreement with the simulation results.
Equivalent circuit models (ECMs) of antennas are developed for their time domain analysis [13], better understanding of their resonance phenomena, and for systematic antenna designs from the equivalent circuit. The equivalent circuit of simple antenna structures with one resonance point can be derived in the form of transmission line models [14-16], frequency independent lumped element resonant structures [17, 18], and physics-based compact lumped structures using the partial element equivalent circuit (PEEC) technique [19]. However, it is difficult to formulate equivalent circuits for complex antenna structures with multiple resonances. The PEEC technique provides the SPICE equivalent lumped element circuit of antennas but it results in a large number of lumped elements in the circuit [19]. In [20], the author derives a dual band PIFA equivalent circuit using radiated and balanced mode analysis, [21] presents a single band PIFA equivalent circuit based on equivalent modes, and [22] shows that a single/dual band high Q PIFA equivalent circuit can be derived using an RLC resonator. To the best knowledge of these authors, the literature only contains PIFA electrical circuit modeling techniques [19-22] for simple PIFA geometries having single/dual band operational characteristics. Cabedo et al. [23] present the electrical modeling of a pentaband PIFA (simple geometry) based on RLC resonators. There is a paucity of literature on equivalent circuit modeling of multiband PIFAs with complex geometries.
The present work also presents a simple way to derive lumped equivalent circuits for multiband PIFAs. The lumped equivalent circuit of the designed dual band PIFA is derived from the rational approximation of its frequency domain response [24]. The frequency response (scattering/admittance parameters) of the antenna is obtained in tabular form through full wave electromagnetic simulation as well as from measurements of the fabricated antenna model. The tabular data is approximated to a rational function using the vector (pole fitting) technique [24, 25]. Subsequently, the lumped elements of the proposed electrical circuit are extracted from the approximated rational function [25, 26]. The derived equivalent circuit is simulated in Advanced Design System (ADS) software. Measured and equivalent circuit model scattering parameters are perfectly matched. Finally, based on the formulated ECM of PIFA geometries with different stub lengths, the correlation between the equivalent circuit (EC) parameter values and the proposed open stub length is discussed in detail. The radiated power is also computed from the formed electric circuits of different PIFA geometries, having good agreement with the radiated power results obtained by full wave electromagnetic simulation in a High Frequency Structural Simulator (HFSS).
The detailed design and analysis of the proposed modification of PIFA structures with different open stub lengths, formulation of their electrical circuits, and the correlation between geometrical and EC parameters are discussed in the following sections.
The initial antenna model, which is used for modification to improve performance, is shown in Fig. 1. The antenna is a dual band PIFA (mostly used in modern cellular devices) having resonance frequencies in GSM 900 (low) and GSM 1800 (high) bands. The simulated model (Fig. 1) of the dual band PIFA depicts that it has a metallic IC near the antenna’s radiating element. The width and height of the printed circuit board (PCB) is 55 mm and 104 mm, respectively, which, in general, is the size of a low-cost 3.5-inch smart phone.
The metallic structure (antenna radiating element, IC, ground) is made of copper, and FR4 substrate is used as the dielectric below the antenna body. The EM analysis of the antenna model is performed in an HFSS. As illustrated in Fig. 1(b), the initial basic antenna radiating element is in the form of a closed loop at the top of a metallic IC. The presence of the metallic structure (IC) in close proximity to the antenna radiating element degrades the radiation properties of the PIFA. To reduce the effect of the IC on the radiation characteristics of the antenna and to improve the other performance metrics of the antenna, the addition of an open stub is proposed at the closed loop end of the PIFA structure. The modified antenna schematic is shown in Fig. 2. The proposed open stub reduces the length of the closed loop part.
The addition of an open stub in the PIFA structure shifts its radiating structure away from the metallic interface connector and ground plane. This shifting enhances the capacitive coupling with the reduction of the ground plane under the antenna radiator, as depicted in Fig. 3. An increase in the strong electric field region between the antenna radiator and the ground plane boosts the electrical volume of the antenna. The product of gain and bandwidth of an antenna has a direct relationship to the antenna volume [27, 28]. The enhancement of the electrical volume of the PIFA with the addition of the proposed stub in its radiating structure increases its bandwidth and improves the return loss, gain, and efficiency characteristics.
In order to avoid any major changes in the resonance frequencies of the original PIFA, it is necessary to maintain the same total electrical lengths in the antenna models with and without the proposed open stub. The length of the open stub can be adjusted while keeping a constant relationship between the stub and the closed loop length. It has been observed through iterative simulations that the same optimum resonance performance of the old and modified PIFA can be obtained using the following simple relationship between the open stub and closed loop length:
In Eq. (1),
Four PIFA models are made to show the effect of the added open stub length on various performance metrics. Simulated PIFA structures with various open stub lengths are shown in Fig. 4. Fig. 4(a), (b), (c), and (d) depict the PIFA geometries with stub lengths (
The predicted
Comparison of predicted S11 and bandwidths (for VSW ≤5) in lower and higher bands with different stub lengths
This section elaborates on the details of the performance of the fabricated PIFAs and its comparison with the simulated results. Dual band PIFA structures with stub lengths of 0 mm and 10.8 mm are fabricated and installed on actual cellular phones (Fig. 6). The metallic structure of the fabricated antennas is made of copper. The real PIFA geometries with stub lengths of 0 mm and 10.8 mm are shown in Fig. 6(b) and (c), respectively. Fig. 6 shows that the metallic IC is located in the vicinity of the radiating element of the actual antenna geometry.
The experimental setup for the
As indicated in Fig. 8, performance of the
The measured radiation patterns for each of the manufac tured antennas at lower and higher resonance frequencies (
The directivity of the PIFA is calculated by approximating the measured radiation pattern as a finite sum over a spherical region [29]. The ratio of the measured gain and directivity indicates the efficiency of the antenna [29]. The correspondence between the measured peak gain (dBi) and the efficiencies of both manufactured antenna geometries is shown in Fig. 12. The modified antenna with a longer added stub length has a more improved gain and efficiency throughout the whole band as compared to the PIFA with no stub. In the modified antenna, a comprehensive improvement of up to 1.8 dBi in gain and 12.4% in efficiency is observed in the whole band.
The simulated and measured
An equivalent circuit model of the antenna is derived to illustrate the correlation between the lumped element values of the equivalent circuit and the proposed stub length in the PIFA structure. Step-by-step details of the proposed formulation of the lumped equivalent circuit of the dual band PIFA with a stub length of 10.8 mm is described in this section.
The first step in the formulation of an equivalent circuit is the rational approximation of the predicted or measured frequency response data. Scattering/admittance parameters versus frequency data of the antenna model can be obtained through complete electromagnetic simulation using the Finite Element Method (FEM), the Finite-Difference Time Domain method (FDTD), the Transmission Line Model (TLM) method, or through hardware measurements. The obtained admittance data is approximated to rational functions using the widely applied vector fitting (VF) or pole fitting method [24, 26]. Vector fitting is a robust numerical technique that is used to convert frequency response data to rational functions. This technique is used for a wide range of microwave and electrical applications [24, 25, 30, 31]; here, it is used to approximate the measured admittance data of the dual band PIFA to Foster’s canonical admittance rational form, Eq. (2). Foster’s canonical admittance rational function [25, 30]
In Eq. (2),
where
These initial poles (starting poles) are defined only at the starting point. The initial poles must have weak attenuation; the procedure and criteria for stating these initial poles is elaborated in [24]. It is shown that if Eq. (3) holds, then the poles of
In Eq. (6),
The procedure used to extract the equivalent circuit component values from the approximated rational function is detailed in this section. The fitted
The poles {
For complex conjugate poles pair there is a relating complex conjugate residual coefficient depicting a series RLCG network (Fig. 13). For this scenario,
For a generalized
Using the circuit network theory, the admittance of the
Comparing Eq. (12) and Eq. (13), the following generalized formulas are obtained for each component of the
The element values of each branch of the series RLCG network can be computed using Eqs. (14)–(16). All branch elements are connected in parallel and the complete schematic of the synthesized equivalent circuit of Eq. (2) is shown in Fig. 13.
The measured PIFA admittance data (
Lower orders of approximation of admittance data produce inaccurate results as at least two CPP are necessary for one resonance frequency for accurate fitting of data using VF. However, higher orders of approximation are unnecessary. The fitting process is carried out with three iterations and results in a root mean square (RMS) error of 3.46
The
[Table 2.] ECM RLCG parameters values for a dual band PIFA
ECM RLCG parameters values for a dual band PIFA
Although the produced equivalent circuit has some negative resistance elements, the overall response of the system is stable and converged as the VF ensures the passivity and stability of the approximated rational function with the shifting of unstable poles to the left-half plane [31, 32]. With the guaranteed stable poles and enforced passivity of the VF technique, the electrical simulation of the circuit will remain stable as the circuit on the whole will always consume power [32]. The number and values of the generated unphysical elements are dependent upon the order of approximation used for fitting and the frequency range of the approximated function. Lower orders of approximation will produce less negative components but it may increase the fitting RMS error. The negative resistance values can be converted to absolute values by using the procedure for resistance inversion described in [30] with the limitation of lower orders of fitting approximation.
The complete process for obtaining simulated/measured admittance data versus frequency, rational approximation of the input frequency response data, extraction of the lumped element parameter values of the equivalent circuit from the approximated rational function, and simulation of the formed equivalent circuit in a circuit simulator for the illustration of its scattering parameters are summarized in the form of a flowchart in Fig. 17.
The proposed method for equivalent circuit formulation is quite simple and good agreement between the electrical circuit and simulated/measured results is obtained. An electrical model for single/multiband antennas can be predicted using the proposed methodology. This described method is used to illustrate the correlation between a PIFA’s geometrical parameters and its respective equivalent circuit element values.
The effect of the proposed open stub length on the performance of dual band PIFAs and the formation of an equivalent circuit from the frequency response has been described in previous sections. Here, we present the study on the correlation between the formed equivalent circuit models of various PIFA geometries (with different stub lengths) and a comparison of the radiation power results.
Rational approximation of the simulated frequency response of dual band PIFA geometries with stub lengths (
The simulated admittance data of PIFA geometry with
Fig. 18 illustrates that the return loss of the simulated and produced equivalent circuits for each PIFA are in good agreement. The difference between the amplitude of the simulated frequency response and the approximated rational function in terms of RMS error is depicted in Fig. 19. All PIFA geometry fitted rational functions have RMS error values in the order of 1e-4. These values can be further reduced with higher orders of approximation; however, this is unnecessary as the RMS error is of a lower order and good frequency response fitting of the respective PIFA is obtained with the used order of approximation. An increase in order will consequently increase the number of RLCG branches, which seems unnecessary.
The details of the correlation between the computed EC parameters of PIFAs with different stub lengths is explained in this section. Fig. 20 illustrates the relationship between the parallel lumped element (
Fig. 21 depicts the correlation between the element values of series RLCG branches of equivalent circuits for different PIFA geometries. The correspondence between the absolute values of the
As elaborated in Fig. 5, significant differences are not observed between the resonance frequencies of all four PIFA models. That is why the above stated ratios for the four equivalent circuits show similar behaviors. The presented correlation study suggests that for wider bandwidth and dipper return loss values for the designed PIFA, the
The radiated power of an electrical circuit is dependent upon the power radiated by its resistive elements. The formed electrical circuit for dual band PIFAs in Section IV constitutes different numbers of resistive components based on their order of approximation (
In Eq. (17),
All the electrical models developed for the different PIFA geometries are simulated in an ADS circuit simulator for the calculations of radiated power from each electrical model using Eq. (18). In addition, the radiated power from the physical geometries of the PIFAs is calculated in an HFSS. A comparison of the radiated power from electrical circuits and the simulated HFSS models is shown in Fig. 22(a), (b), (c), and (d), which depict the results of normalized radiated power for PIFA structures with stub lengths of 0 mm, 2.8 mm, 6.8 mm, and 10.8 mm, respectively. It can be seen that the normalized radiated power results of the simulated PIFA geometries and the developed equivalent circuit models are in good agreement.
The presented results show that electrical circuits formed using the proposed methodology of rational fitting can be used to depict the various radiation characteristics of the antenna, which are closely related to the computed radiation properties, using a full wave electromagnetic simulation in much less time than the computation time required to complete simulation in EM software.
The advantages of the proposed equivalent circuit modeling, correlation analysis, and radiated power computation are summarized as follows:
This work presented a design, analysis, and simple method for the formulation of lumped equivalent circuit models for dual band PIFAs. The presence of a metallic interface connector around the PIFA radiating structure degrades its radiating power, return loss, and bandwidth performance. It has been shown that the addition of the proposed open stub to the PIFA geometry improves the various performance metrics of a PIFA. PIFA models with various open stub lengths were created to illustrate the effect of the length on PIFA performance, and it was found that the enhancement of PIFA characteristics was proportional to the stub length. The predicted and measured PIFA results confirm up to 4.6 dB, 17%, 2 dBi, and 12.4% improvements in return loss, bandwidth, gain, and efficiency values, respectively. The second presented work illustrates a simple procedure for the modeling of a lumped equivalent circuit for the designed dual band PIFAs. The measured/simulated admittance data for each PIFA geometry with different stub lengths were approximated to a rational function using a pole fitting method. Subsequently, a lumped equivalent circuit was formed and its element values were derived from the fitted rational functions of each geometry. The predicted/measured and formed equivalent circuit scattering parameters agreed extremely well. Finally, the correspondence between the physical stub length of various PIFA structures and their derived equivalent circuits was discussed in detail, which will be useful in the examination of the relationship between actual designed PIFA structures and their equivalent circuits.