Approximate natural vibration analysis of rectangular plates with openings using assumed mode method
- Author: Cho Dae Seung, Vladimir Nikola, Choi Tae Muk
- Organization: Cho Dae Seung; Vladimir Nikola; Choi Tae Muk
- Publish: International Journal of Naval Architecture and Ocean Engineering Volume 5, Issue3, p478~491, 30 Sep 2013
Natural vibration analysis of plates with openings of different shape represents an important issue in naval architecture and ocean engineering applications. In this paper, a procedure for vibration analysis of plates with openings and arbitrary edge constraints is presented. It is based on the assumed mode method, where natural frequencies and modes are determined by solving an eigenvalue problem of a multi-degree-of-freedom system matrix equation derived by using Lagrange's equations of motion. The presented solution represents an extension of a procedure for natural vibration analysis of rectangular plates without openings, which has been recently presented in the literature. The effect of an opening is taken into account in an intuitive way, i.e. by subtracting its energy from the total plate energy without opening. Illustrative numerical examples include dynamic analysis of rectangular plates with rectangular, elliptic, circular as well as oval openings with various plate thicknesses and different combinations of boundary conditions. The results are compared with those obtained by the finite element method (FEM) as well as those available in the relevant literature, and very good agreement is achieved.
Natural vibration analysis , Flexural vibrations , Assumed mode method , Lagrange's equations , Rectangular plate , Plate opening , Arbitrary boundary constraints.
Dynamic analysis of plates with openings represents an important issue in naval architecture and civil, mechanical as well as ocean engineering. Problem of determining flexural natural frequencies of plates with central free openings has been studied by many researchers (Leissa, 1969; Monahan et al., 1970; Bathe et al., 1973; Paramasivam, 1973; Hegarty and Ariman, 1975; Ali and Atwal, 1980; Laura et al., 1987; Gutierrez et al., 1987). Nowadays, the finite element method gives complete solution to a problem of vibration of plates with openings, and although it applied for very long time (Monahan et al., 1970), it still suffers from the computational time consumption. Finite difference method has been applied to a plate with opening and simply supported and clamped edges by Paramasivam (1973). Reddy (1982) analysed large amplitude flexural vibrations of layered composite plates with openings. Grossi et al. (1997) applied optimized Rayleigh-Ritz method to generate values of the fundamental frequency coefficient corresponding to the first fully antisymmetric mode for rectangular plates with circular holes and elastically restrained against rotation. In all these references positions of the openings are limited to plate central part. However, finite difference method has been applied to a plate with more than two openings by Aksu and Ali (1976). Huang and Sakiyama (1999) proposed approximate method for free vibration analysis of rectangular plates with openings of different shapes (circular, semi-circular, elliptic, square, rectangular, triangular, etc.). They consider a plate with an opening as a body with non-uniform thickness, where the opening is treated as an extremely thin part of the plate. In that sense the problem is translated into the free vibration analysis of the equivalent rectangular plate with non-uniform thickness by applying the discrete solution (Huang and Sakiyama, 1998). It should be noted that the problem is solved for arbitrary position of the opening within the plate area. An extensive literature survey on vibration analysis of rectangular plates with openings, with particular emphasis to application of Rayleigh-Ritz method, has been presented by Kwak and Han (2007). They proposed a Rayleigh-Ritz based method with different coordinate systems for a plate and opening with particular aim to simplify integration process in total energy determination.
Recently, assumed mode method using characteristic orthogonal polynomials is applied to problem of free vibration of rectangular plates of arbitrary edge constraints (Chung et al., 1993; Kim et al., 2012). In this paper, assumed mode method is applied to natural vibration analysis of plates with openings of different shape and arbitrary boundary conditions. The opening effect is accounted for by subtracting its strain and kinetic energies from corresponding total plate energies without openings. Natural frequencies and corresponding mode shapes are obtained by solving an eigenvalue problem of a multi-degree-offreedom system matrix equation, which has been derived by Lagrange's equations of motion. It should be noted also that the proposed method can be applied for arbitrary number of openings and their arbitrary positions. Numerical examples include analysis of natural vibrations of rectangular plates with rectangular, elliptic, circular and oval openings. Both, thin and thick plates are considered. The results are compared with those obtained by the finite element method as well as some results available in the relevant literature. It is shown that the presented procedure can be used as a reliable alternative to widely used FEM, which may require much more time in model preparation, as for instance in case of plate with oval opening.
The Mindlin thick plate theory, which takes shear influence and rotary inertia into account, is introduced (Mindlin et al., 1956). In that way the method can be applied not only to thin plates, but also to moderately thick and thick ones. The Mindlin theory deals with three general displacements, i.e. plate deflection
w, and angles of cross-section rotation about xand yaxis, ψxand ψy, respectively. From the equilibrium of sectional forces (bending moments, torsional moments and shear forces) and inertia forces, equations of motions are derived:
ρis plate density, his plate thickness, kis shear coefficient, while νis Poisson’s ratio. Further on, Drepresents plate flexural rigidity D= Eh3 / (12(1？ ν2)) , while Eand G= E/(2(1+ ν)) are Young’s and shear modulus, respectively.
The basic idea to account for an opening effect is to subtract the energy of the opening part from the total plate energy without openings. In that sense, following expressions for the strain and kinetic energy of rectangular plate with openings, respectively, are valid:
Vpand Voare strain energies and Tpand Toare kinetic energies of plate and opening, respectively.
By introducing non-dimensional parameters
ξ= x/ a, η= y/ b, α= a/ band S= kGh/ Dfor a rectangular plate of length aand breadth b, one can write for the strain and kinetic energy of rectangular plate without openings, Vand T, respectively (Kim et al., 2012):
K Tx1) = ( K Tx1 a/ kGh), ( K Tx2) = ( K Tx2 a/ kGh), ( K Ty1) = ( K Ty1 b/ kGh) and ( K Ty2) = ( K Ty2 b/ kGh) re non-dimensional stiffness at x= 0, x= a, y= 0 and y= b, respectively, and correspond to the translational spring constants per unit length K Tx1, K Tx2, K Ty1 and K Ty2 shown in Fig. 1. In the same manner, ( K Rx1) = ( K Rx1 a/ D), ( K Rx2) = ( K Rx2 a/ D), ( K Ry1) = ( K Ry1 b/ D) and ( K Ry2) = ( K Ry2 b/ D), are for the rotational spring constants per unit length K Rx1, K Rx2, K Ry1 and K Ry2 shown in Fig. 1, respectively. In Fig. 1 the following quantities are related to xdirection: a, K Tx1, K Tx2, K Rx1 and K Rx2. Other quantities ( b, K Ty1, K Ty2 K Ry1 and K Ry2) are relevant for ydirection.
In similar way, as for a plate without openings, one can write for strain and kinetic energy of rectangular opening shown in Fig. 2, respectively:
In Fig. 2
xroand yrodenote longitudinal and transverse coordinate of rectangular opening centre of gravity and aroand broare one half of its length and breadth.
Analogously to the rectangular opening, strain and kinetic energies of elliptical opening shown in Fig. 3 yield:
If one introduces
xeo= yeoin the Eq. (10) and (11), strain and kinetic energies of circular opening is obtained. Similarly as in previous case, in Fig. 3 xeoand yeodenote longitudinal and transverse coordinate of elliptic opening centre of gravity, while and aeoand beoare opening major and minor semi-axis, respectively.
Oval opening, which often appears in ships and offshore structures, can be treated as a combination of rectangular and circular openings, Fig. 4., where
xooand yoeoare longitudinal and transverse coordinate of oval opening centre of gravity, while and aooand booare equal to one half of its length and breadth, respectively.
In that way its strain and kinetic energies can be written in following form:
and can be calculated by above listed formulae.
If one wants to apply developed procedure for more than one opening, opening strain and kinetic energies have to be calculated separately, and subtracted from the corresponding energies of plate without openings.
In the assumed mode method, lateral displacement and the rotational angles are expressed by superposing products of orthogonal polynomials:
Xm( ξ), Yn( η), Θm( ξ) and Φn( η) are the orthogonal polynomials satisfying the specified elastic edge constraints with respect to ξand η. Furthermore, amn( t), bmn( t) and cmn( t) are the influence coefficients of orthogonal polynomials. Also, Mand Nare the number of orthogonal polynomials used for approximate solution in ξand ηdirection, respectively. Eqs. (14), (15) and (16) can be alternatively written in matrix form:
By substituting the Eq. (4) and (5) into Lagrange's equation of motion below
the discrete matrix equation with 3x
Mx Ndegrees of freedom can be obtained as the following equation:
where [M] and [K] are the mass and the stiffness matrix, respectively, and their constitution is described in details in Kim et al. (2012).
If we assume harmonic vibrations, i.e.
Eq. (22) leads to an eigenvalue problem which gives natural frequencies and eigenvectors of the system, where
jis the unit imaginary and ωrepresents the angular frequency. The mode shape corresponding to each natural frequency is obtained from the following equation:
lrepresents the order of mode. It should be noted here that when using the assumed mode method, the orthogonal polynomials corresponding to the property of target model should be applied to achieve accurate analysis. For this purpose, the characteristic orthogonal polynomials having the property of Timoshenko beam functions which satisfies the specified edge constraints are used, and their complete derivation is presented by Kim et al. (2012).
In addition, it should be mentioned that developed procedure is not fully physical consistent, since in the Rayleigh-Ritz method all assumed shape function should satisfy at least geometric boundary conditions (Szilard, 2004), which is not unconditionally the case in the presented procedure at the opening boundaries. Namely, it is necessary to say that there exists differrence in real boundary conditions at the free opening edge and remained after excluding that part. In the former case boundary forces are zero, while in the latter case they are equal to the sectional forces. However, if opening dimensions are not too large comparing the plate dimensions, the procedure should normally give quite accurate and reliable results.
In order to illustrate applicability of the developed procedure, natural vibration analyses of plates with different openings are carried out. Just for the illustration purposes, first, a rectangular plate without openings as a very simple case with available analytical solution is analysed. Then, rectangular plate with single central rectangular opening is analysed. Further on, the procedure is applied to rectangular plate with central elliptic opening. Also, plate with two elliptic openings is analysed as well as a rectangular plate with central circular opening. Finally, results of vibration analysis of a rectangular plate with oval opening, which is typical in naval architecture, are presented. The number of polynomials has been set to 13 in all examples, for both
ξand ηdirections, respectively, after convergence test. The values of Young's modulus, material density and Poisson's ratio are the same in all numerical examples and their values are set to 2.1×1011 N/ m2, 7850 kg/ m3and 0.3, respectively. Furthermore, the value of shear factor kis adjusted to 0.86667 in all calculations. In all numerical examples, the results obtained by the proposed procedure are denoted with PS (Present Solution).
A numerical calculation of the natural frequencies has been carried out for a plate without openings, simply supported on the longitudinal edges and clamped on the transversal ones SCSC (simple-clamped-simple-clamped), according to the procedure described in previous section. In Table 1, the frequency parameter
λis presented for two different relative thickness ratios h/ b, which include thin and moderately thick plate. Non-dimensional frequency parameter is calculated according to following formula:
where the value of natural frequency
ωis given in rad/s. In this case the obtained results are compared with recently presented analytical solutions (Xing and Liu, 2009; Senjanovi？ et al., 2013), as well as with numerical results obtained by finite element method (MSC, 2010). Generally, it is obvious from the shown results, Table 1, that the developed procedure provides very good results comparing to the analytical solution.
Rectangular plate with length and breadth 1.0
mand 0.7 m, respectively, is considered. Dimensions of the central opening are 0.2×0.1 m, and different relative thickness ratios h/ aare taken into account. Values of the first 3 natural frequencies, calculated according to the developed procedure together with finite element solutions obtained by MSC/NASTRAN (MSC, 2010), are listed in Table 2. Different combinations of edge constraints, i.e. SSSS (simple-simple-simple-simple), CCCC (clamped- clamped-clamped-clamped) and FCSC (free-clamped-simple-clamped), have been analysed. The agreement of the natural frequencies is quite good, especially bearing in mind the fact that dimensions of an opening are quite large comparing to plate dimensions. Natural modes for some selected cases are presented in Figs. 5 and 6, where also good agreement is obvious.
Natural vibration analysis of rectangular plate of same dimensions as in previous case, with central elliptic opening and two elliptic openings at arbitrary defined locations has been also performed. In the former case, the dimensions of the opening are 0.2
aeo= mand 0.1 beo= m, while in the latter one 0.08 aeo= mand 0.15 beo= m. Due to reason of simplicity, only FSCS case is analysed. In this case also reasonable agreement between both, natural frequencies listed in Table 3, and natural modes shown in Figs. 7 and 8, is achieved.
Mathematical model for vibration analysis of rectangular plates with circular openings of radius
Rrepresents a special case of a plate with elliptic opening, and that means the above formulae for case of elliptic opening are valid if aeo= bbo= R. In this case the obtained results are compared to those presented by Grossi et al. (1997), where natural frequencies, obtained by optimized Rayleigh-Ritz method, are converted in dimensionless frequency parameters. The comparison with FEM results is also provided. Non-dimensional frequency parameters Ωijobtained for a rectangular plate with different length to breadth, a/ b, and diameter to length ratios, η= 2R/ a, respectively, are calculated according to following expression:
Comparison of non-dimensional vibration parameters for rectangular plate with circular openings, Tables 4 and 5, actually shows that developed procedure as well as optimized Rayleigh-Ritz method (Grossi et al., 1997) overestimate natural frequencies. However, comparing to optimized Rayleigh-Ritz method which is more complex, developed procedure gives closer results to those obtained by finite element method, which may be considered as the most accurate ones. Also, comparison of natural modes in this case, Fig. 9, shows good agreement.
Finally, natural vibration analysis of rectangular plate with oval opening has been performed. It should be noted that oval
type opening is widely adopted in the ship and offshore structures, but at the same time its FE modelling is rather time-consuming task. In that sense, application of the presented method to this problem is advantageous.
Plate length and breadth yield 0.7
mand 0.5 m, respectively, while oval opening dimensions are 0.1 aoo= mand 0.05 boo= m. First three natural frequencies of rectangular plate with oval opening, for different relative thickness and boundary conditions, respectively, are shown in Table 6. Corresponding mode shapes for a selected case are presented in Fig. 10. Similarly as in previous cases, acceptable agreement of the results is achieved.
Influence of the opening size on plate natural frequencies is considered analyzing natural vibrations of rectangular plate with length and breadth 2.0
mand 1.0 m, respectively, and plate thickness equal to 0.03 m. Due to reason of simplicity, CCCC boundary conditions are applied, and ratios of opening and plate areas, Ao, and, Ap, respectively, has been varied from zero to 0.20. As expected, the best agreement of the result is achieved in case of plate without openings, Fig. 11. Although the difference increases with the opening increase, it still remains acceptable for larger opening size.
Concerning the opening size influence on natural frequency, it differs from one natural mode to another. One can notice that natural frequency of the fundamental mode slightly increases, while the second doesn’t changes too much. Third natural mode is particularly interesting when increasing
Ao/ Apratio from 0.1 to 0.15, where natural frequency doesn’t increase. This effect is actually a result of mode shape change as can be seen in Fig. 12.
An approximate procedure for natural vibration analysis of rectangular plates with openings and arbitrary edge constraints is presented. The opening effect is accounted for in a very simple and intuitive way, i.e. by subtracting its strain and kinetic energies from the corresponding total plate energies. Numerical examples, which include analysis of natural vibrations of rectangular plates with variable thicknesses and with different opening shapes (rectangular, elliptic, circular, oval) and sizes show very good agreement with the results obtained by FEM as well as to some results that are presented in the relevant literature. Moreover, despite its simplicity, the presented procedure can give even closer results to FEM comparing to some more complex methods, as shown in the case of rectangular plate with circular opening. Anyhow, it should be mentioned that the procedure should be applied to plates with smaller openings comparing to plate dimensions, as for instance to vibration analysis of swash bulkheads with small openings etc. Thus, it can be used as a reliable alternative to widely used FEM, which may require much more time in model preparation, which is especially pronounced in case of rectangular plate with oval opening. Future investigations should be focused on the application of assumed mode method to vibration analysis of more complex structural members of ships and offshore structures, as for instance stiffened panels, stiffened panels with openings of different shape, rectangular plates with openings or stiffened panels partially or fully immersed into the water, etc.
[Fig. 1] Rectangular plate elastically supported in translational and rotational directions.
[Fig. 2] Rectangular plate with rectangular opening.
[Fig. 3] Rectangular plate with elliptic opening.
[Fig. 4] Rectangular plate with oval opening.
[Table 1] Frequency parameter λ of rectangular plate without openings, SCSC edge constraints.
[Table 2] Natural frequency f (Hz) of rectangular plate with central rectangular opening.
[Fig. 5] Mode shapes of rectangular plate with central rectangular opening, h = 0.01m, SSSS.
[Fig. 6] Mode shapes of rectangular plate with central rectangular opening, h = 0.01m, FCSC.
[Table 3] Natural frequencies f (Hz) of rectangular plate with elliptic openings.
[Fig. 7] Mode shapes of rectangular plate with central elliptic opening, h = 0.05m, FSCS.
[Fig. 8] Mode shapes of rectangular plate with two elliptic openings, h = 0.05m, FSCS.
[Table 4] Frequency parameter Ωij and its difference in % between FEM and other method of rectangular plate with circular opening, CCCC edge constraints.
[Table 5] Frequency parameter Ωij and its difference in % between FEM and other method of rectangular plate with circular opening, CSCS edge constraints.
[Fig. 9] Mode shapes of rectangular plate with central circular opening, a / b =1, η = 0.2 , CCCC.
[Table 6] Natural frequencies f (Hz) of rectangular plate with oval opening.
[Fig. 10] Mode shapes of rectangular plate with oval opening, h = 0.05m, CFCC.
[Fig. 11] Natural frequencies of a plate with different sizes of rectangular opening, CCCC.
[Fig. 12] Third natural mode of a plate with different sizes of rectangular opening, CCCC.