Undergraduate courses for enhancing design ability in naval architecture
- Author: Lee Kyu-Yeul, Ku Namkug, Cha Ju-Hwan
- Organization: Lee Kyu-Yeul; Ku Namkug; Cha Ju-Hwan
- Publish: International Journal of Naval Architecture and Ocean Engineering Volume 5, Issue3, p364~375, 30 Sep 2013
Contemporary lectures in undergraduate engineering courses typically focus on teaching major technical knowledge-based theories in a limited time. Therefore, most lectures do not allow the students to gain understanding of how the theories are applied, especially in Naval Architecture and Ocean Engineering departments. Shipyards require students to acquire practical ship design skills in undergraduate courses. To meet this requirement, two lectures are organized by the authors; namely, “Planning Procedure of Naval Architecture & Ocean Engineering” (PNAOE) and “Innovative Ship Design” (ISD). The concept of project-based and collaborative learning is applied in these two lectures. In the PNAOE lecture, sophomores receive instruction in the designing and building of model ships, and the students’ work is evaluated in a model ship contest. This curriculum enables students to understand the concepts of ship design and production. In the ISD lecture, seniors learn how to develop their creative ideas about ship design and communicate with members of group. They are encouraged to cooperate with others and understand the ship design process. In the capstone design course, students receive guidance to facilitate understanding of how the knowledge from their sophomore or junior classes, such as fluid mechanics, statics, and dynamics, can be applied to practical ship design. Students are also encouraged to compete in the ship design contest organized by the Society of Naval Architects of Korea. Moreover, the effectiveness of project-based and collaborative learning for enhancing interest in the shipbuilding Industry and understanding the ship design process is demonstrated by citing the PNAOE and ISD lectures as examples.
Capstone design , Naval architecture , Design ability , Project-based learning , Collaborative learning.
The conventional undergraduate engineering curriculum is based on classroom lectures and mainly focused on teaching theories and technical knowledge. However, this curriculum does not enable students to develop design abilities they need to keep up with the rapid progress in engineering. Especially in the field of naval architecture, the huge scale of ships and offshore structures, which are the main products of naval architecture, make it difficult for students to understand the relationship between theory and engineering design. Therefore, two courses were organized by the authors specifically for undergraduates; namely, “PNAOE” and “ISD”. PNAOE is a lecture that aims to enhance sophomores’ interest in naval architecture. ISD, on the other hand, is a capstone design course for seniors.
Project-based learning is where students are assigned a project to execute and take the initiative to solve project-related problems. It is very effective for developing students’ practical design ability (Hanai et al., 2007; Ito et al., 2007; Matsuzawa and Ohiwa, 2007).
Besides project-based learning, collaborative learning is also an important and effective learning method. Terenzini et al. (2001) examined the students of undergraduate engineering courses, who are taught using collaborative learning methods, and found they differed from traditional lecture and discussion courses in their ability to promote the development of engineering design, problem-solving, communication, and group participation skills. Moreover, according to Gokhale (1995) and Goodsell et al. (1992), collaborative learning increases participants’ interest, promotes critical thinking through the active exchange of ideas in small groups, and can help students develop the sense of community. Shared learning also gives students an opportunity to engage in discussion and it makes them to achieve at higher levels of thought and retain information longer than students who work quietly as individuals (Johnson and Johnson, 1986; Totten et al., 1991).
Because of these merits of project-based and collaborative learning, the students of two lectures (i.e., PNAOE and ISD) are required to form small groups to complete term projects. This paper presents the objectives, contents, characteristics, and learning outcomes of the two courses. This paper is based on the author’s textbooks (Lee et al., 2011) and lecture notes (Lee, 2006; Lee, 2009).
In this course, students are encouraged to (1) increase their interests in naval architecture and (2) learn how to apply their knowledge in ship designing. This lecture is comprised of “Designing a Model Ship,” and “Constructing a Model Ship.”
This is a sophomore course (PNAOE) in which students build a model ship in 15 weeks as a term project, and a model ship contest is held to evaluate the achievement of the students. Students design and build a model ship in accordance with the given subjects. The contest evaluates the speed and maneuverability of each model ship. We use the term “project” to encourage students’ interest in naval architecture by learning the relationship between practical ship designing and theory.
Determining the main dimensions of a ship
In this course, students learn what the main dimensions are and how to determine them. The main dimensions, such as length (L), breadth (B), depth (D), draft (T) and block coefficient (CB), have to satisfy certain design criteria, such as physical, economic, and regulatory constraints. Among these constraints, physical constraint is the most important because they are related to floatability of a ship. The basic theories that the students learn for determining a ship’s main dimensions are as follows.
？ Hydrostatic equilibrium
For a ship to float, its total weight must be equal to the buoyancy force exerted on the immersed body.
？ Archimedes’ principle
The buoyancy force exerted on an immersed body has the same magnitude as the weight of the fluid displaced by the immersed body.
？ Total weight of a ship
The weight of a commercial ship is usually comprised of the lightweight and the deadweight. According to the definition of these weights, the physical constraint, the so-called weight equation, is described as follows:
FBuoyant = Wdisplacement = Wtotal
F Buoyantis the force exerted on a ship, W displacementis the weight of the fluid displaced by the immersed body, and W totalis a ship’s total weight.
Wtotal = LWT + DWT
where LWT is lightweight and DWT is deadweight, we get the following equation.
Wdisplacement = LWT + DWT
At this point, displacement can be represented in terms of the main dimensions. The deadweight is given by the owner’s requirement. Therefore, the lightweight should be estimated using the appropriate assumption. Because a ship consists of the hull structure, outfit, and machinery, the lightweight can also be estimated as follows.
LWT = Ws + Wm + Wo
where Ws is steel weight, Wm is machinery weight, and Wo is outfit weight. Ws, Wm, and Wo can be assumed to depend on the main dimensions and can be estimated by the weight of the basis ship. The physical constraint is used to roughly determine the main dimensions. After hull form variation, the main dimensions are precisely determined.
Hull form design, compartment design, and structural design using software
To help students determine the main dimensions and design the hull form, compartment, and structure of a ship, software such as EzOptimizer, EzHULL, EzCOMPART, and EzSTRUCT are provided. The software has been jointly developed by the author’s laboratory (Advanced Ship Design Automation Laboratory, Department of Naval Architecture and Ocean Engineering, Seoul National University) and EzGRAPH Co., Ltd. Students learn in the lectures how to use the software. The procedures of ship design using the software are as follows.
？ First, students design the hull form of the model ship using the commercial software “EzHULL” (see Fig. 1).
？ Second, students design the compartment of the model ship using “EzCOMPART” (see Fig. 2). In this procedure, the stability of the ship and the capacity of each compartment are checked.
？ Third, students design the structural members of the model ship using “EzSTRUCT” (see Fig. 3). In this procedure, the strength of the model ship is checked.
Students construct a model ship based on the theory explained in Chapter 1. Each year, various subjects for the term projects are suggested in this lecture, and the subjects are listed in Appendix B. In this section, the procedure of constructing the model ship is presented using an example of the term projects.
？ Finally, students paint the model ship to make it waterproof and refine the hull form. After constructing the model ship, students examine the performance of their model ship using a trial run in a towing tank (110
min length, 8 min width, 3.5 min depth). The towing tank is the equipment of the department of Naval Architecture and Ocean Engineering of Seoul National University in Korea. Fig. 8 shows the trial run of a model ship.
The contest evaluates the model ship according to the following criteria.
？ Speed: how long it takes to go to the specified location.
？ Maneuverability: how long it takes to go to the specified location and return to the departure point.
To encourage students’ interest in naval architecture, there are several awards in the contest such as best speed, best maneuverability, and best creative design. Students are also graded according to their model ship’s performance in the contest.
The goal of this capstone design course is to (1) develop students’ ship designing skills, (2) develop students’ ability to solve engineering problems using the knowledge gained from their previous lectures, and (3) acquire teamwork and communication skills with other people in a group.
The course introduces students to the following basic concepts of ship designing.
○ Weights of ship
○ Hull structure
○ Hull form design
○ Ship stability
○ General arrangement
A team of 6-8 students complete a term project based on the given owner’s requirements regarding the following tasks:
○ Determination of principal dimensions of ship
○ Estimation of cargo hold volume
○ Prediction of speed and power
○ Selection of main engine
○ General arrangement design
○ Structural design of the midship section
○ Estimation of weight
○ Calculation of freeboard
○ Determination of propeller principal dimensions
○ Design of hull form by hull form variation method
○ Naval architectural calculation such as volume hydrostatics, trim & stability, and longitudinal strength
To help students complete the tasks, the following procedure is used.
(1) Find applied problems.
(2) Construct mathematical models.
(3) Find a solving scheme (algorithm).
(4) Develop software.
(5) Write reports and make presentations.
For example, (1) if students need to determine ship’s main dimensions, (2) they will construct a mathematical model using physical, economic, and regulatory constraints. To determine the optimal dimensions, they will set up the objective function. (3) They will then find the solving scheme (4) and will develop the optimization software using the technical knowledge acquired in their sophomore or junior classes. (5) After that, students will report and present the results of the term projects, including the procedure for completing the tasks.
Several types of ships or ship automation systems are suggested as subjects for the term projects. Fig. 9 shows the configuration of this course and examples of the subjects for the term projects. The subjects for the term projects are revised annually in accordance with the needs of the shipbuilding industry.
Students select subjects for the term project and use their technical knowledge to complete it. Moreover, this lecture guides students in the development and use of their own software (see Figs. 12 and 13). Through the software development process, students learn exactly where the technical knowledge is applied and how the software is developed.
An example of the term project, the basic design process of the “25,000 displacement ton light aircraft carrier” is shown in the following figures (Figs. 10-17) and Table 1. Figs. 12-14 show the uses of the software developed by the students for completing the tasks. All the subjects of the term projects, provided in this lecture, are listed in Appendix A.
To give students an opportunity to have their achievements assessed, this course encourages them to compete in the ship design contest organized by the Society of Naval Architects of Korea. Students who join the contest usually manifest more interest in ship design and achieve higher grades than other students.
In the ship design contest, students always received one of top 3 prizes. The results of the contests are listed in Appendix A. For the contest, teams from ISD prepared for 6 weeks, and the teams consisted of 6-8 students. The other teams prepared for 54 weeks, and consisted of 10-20 students. This demonstrates how the ISD course is intensive and effective for improving students’ design skills.
This paper presented the curricula and results of two courses based on collaborative and project-based learning. These two lectures were established to enhance undergraduates’ design ability. During the course, students learned the applications of the technical knowledge that they had gained in their sophomore or junior classes. Software for the course was developed by students and also partially provided by the author’s laboratory. Students participated in a model ship contest and a ship designing contest, which motivated their interest in naval architecture. The results of the ship design contest show the lectures were effecttive and intensive for enhancing students’ design ability. In the future, the subjects for the projects in the two lectures will be updated to reflect the latest issues in the naval architecture industry.
4. Ito A., Watanabe Y., Kurematsu A., Murakami H., Yuyama I., Miyamichi J., Hasegawa H., Hososhima M., Tsukikawa A., Fujii M. 2007 Issues on business-academia collaboration in the development of educational course; For the design, development and implementation of practical cell phone software. [IPSJ Journal] Vol.48 P.846-857
[Fig. 1] Designing the hull form using “EzHull”.
[Fig. 2] Designing the compartment using “EzCOMPART”.
[Fig. 3] Structural design using “EzSTRUCT”.
[Fig. 4] The structural members of a model ship.
[Fig. 5] Assembly of the structural members.
[Fig. 6] Attaching the shell plates to the frames of a model ship.
[Fig. 7] The hull form after attaching the shell plates.
[Fig. 8] Trial run of a model ship.
[Fig. 9] Configuration of the “Innovative Ship Design” course.
[Fig. 10] Hanger design of the light aircraft carrier.
[Fig. 11] Deck design of the light aircraft carrier.
[Fig. 12] Hydrostatics calculation using the software developed by students.
[Fig. 13] Resistance estimation using the software developed by students.
[Fig. 14] Determination of the main dimensions of the propeller using the software developed by students.
[Table 1] Main dimensions of the light aircraft carrier.
[Fig. 15] Design of light aircraft carrier’s hull form using “EzHULL”.
[Fig. 16] Design of light aircraft carrier’s compartments using “EzCOMPART”.
[Fig. 17] Structural design of the light aircraft carrier using “EzSTRUCT”.