Angular Effect of Virtual Vertices Inserted to Treat The Boundary Edges on an Infinite Conducting Surface
- Author: Hwang Ji-Hwan, Kweon Soon-Koo, Oh Yisok
- Organization: Hwang Ji-Hwan; Kweon Soon-Koo; Oh Yisok
- Publish: Journal of electromagnetic engineering and science Volume 13, Issue1, p16~21, 31 March 2013
This study presents the angular effects of virtual vertices inserted for effective treatment of the boundary edge laid on an infinite conducting surface in a half-space scattering problem. We investigated the angular effects of virtual vertices by first computing the radar cross section (RCS) of a specific scatterer; i.e., a tilted conducting plate in contact with the ground surface, by inserting the virtual vertex in half-space. Here, the electric field integral equation is used to solve this problem with various virtual vertex angles (
θv) and conducting plate inclination angles ( θr) ranging from 0° to 180°. The effects of the angles θvand θron the RCS computation are clearly shown with numerical results with and without the virtual vertices in free- and half-spaces.
Electric Field Integral Equation (EFIE) , Half-Space Scattering , Image Theory , RWG Basis , Virtual Vertex.
In In the field of remote sensing and earth observation utilizing microwave radar systems, the method of moments (MoM) with the Rao-Wilton-Glisson (RWG) basis function and its derivatives is widely used to compute the scattering properties of an arbitrary object , . Recently, the use of this numerical analysis technique has been proposed in various studies to analyze the scattering property in half-space, which includes multiple scattering between scattering particles and bottom surfaces , . Development of these numerical techniques is very useful in the remote sensing of earth terrain because the scattering process from scatterers randomly placed on a flat surface, such as a water surface or ground plane, can be represented well by a half-space scattering that applies the image theory or the impedance boundary condition .
In particular, due to the edges laid on the interface, the placement of a scatterer on an infinite conducting or impedance surface results in complications in computational processes such as singularity or inaccurate calculations by original sources and their images on the same surface. Image theory ,  and a recent study  do not consider this contact problem, so some ambiguity exists for numerically solving the scattering property of a flat surface that includes various scatterers. Thus, we effectively solved this issue on the half-space scattering problem using the MoM process with RWG basis function by proposing a virtual vertex technique whereby the contact surface of the scatterer can be removed and replaced by the half-RWG basis of the boundary edge on the interface of half-space and an additionally inserted virtual vertex , and we clearly show its angular effect in this study.
Virtual vertices inserted for effective treatment of the problematic boundary edges in half-space scattering can be located essentially at any position of the upper halfspace, including the interface. One of the possible solutions is to place them on the interface of the half-space. In this case, a half-RWG basis vector generated by the virtual vertex has only tangential vector components, which will be canceled by their images when we apply an exact image theory to solve the half-space scattering problem, such as a conducting hemisphere laid on an infinite conducting surface , .
However, several arguments about the effect of virtual vertexes persist. For example, in the case of a scattering object that includes a scattering surface perpendicular to the ground surface, we usually encounter singular points when the electric field integral equation (EFIE) is used to solve the problem because the projection of orthogonal vectors becomes zero. Therefore, the virtual vertex in this case does not contribute to a computational result and even frequently creates a singularity in the computational procedure , . In other words, when the original half-RWG basis vector and the added half- RWG basis by the virtual vertex are perpendicular, the effectiveness of the insertion of a virtual vertex becomes questionable.
We investigated the effect of the position of a virtual vertex by first introducing a conducting plate whose side (boundary edge) is attached to the ground surface, as shown in Fig. 1, with an inclination angle
θr; and inserting a virtual vertex at an arbitrary position with a virtual vertex angle θvand a vertex distance dfrom the center of the boundary edge ( vc). In effect, a relatively small distance dwith respect to the length of boundary edge did not affect the computational result. The interaction between the virtual vertex and the boundary edge at various angles of θvand θrwas then numerically simulated in the half- and free-space problems.
In the present study, we discuss the angular effect of virtual vertices. When we apply existing numerical techniques , ,  to solve the half-space scattering problem, an optimal position for a virtual vertex will be determined to provide accurate numerical results for scattering from an arbitrary object on a conducting surface. The EFIE was used in the present study to compute these scattering problems with an open-structure, such as a conducting plate.
The geometrical parameters associated with an arbitrary virtual vertex in the upper half-space and the floating boundary edge on the interface are shown in Fig. 1. Insertion of a virtual vertex results in incorporation of a half RWG basis of the boundary edge into the MoM process to depict the vertical current components passing through it , , . The angular effect of a virtual vertex in an arbitrary angle is examined by computing the scattering properties of test objects with various angles of
We computed the scattering property of a test object with various angles using the modified integral equation with the original current sources and their images. The original current sources
and their images
are expressed as shown in (1) and (2) .
The scattered fields
due to the original and image curent sources can be represented as shown in (3) .
where subscript ‘
i’ implies image current sources to depict the reflected waves from the infinite ground plane in the half-space. We should mention that the sum of scattered fields in (3a) must be calculated separately for vertical and horizontal components with respect to the ground plane because the horizontal vector components have opposite directions in their images. The scattered fields
were computed using numerical integration with Gaussian quadrature over triangle  and analytic integration for singularity extraction from self-cells . In particular, this analytic integration may cause another singularity if the observation vector
(a projection of observation vector
) lies anywhere along an edge. In this case, we moved the observation point a very small distance (
ea, it has a range of 10？15 λ0< eb≤10？10 λ0) away from the edge, as in .
are position vectors of the original and updated positions for the observation point and
？is a unit vector normal to the edge .
We examined the angular effect of virtual vertices by first computing the RCS of a 1
λ0×1 λ0 square conducting plate at 10 MHz at various values of θvand θr. Figs. 2(a) and (b) show the test setup with the inclined conducting plate placed on the infinite ground plane and its equivalent test setup in free-space, respectively. Fig. 2(c) shows a geometrical configuration of the problematic boundary edge, with virtual vertices at various angular positions ( θv). We cross-checked the influence of the boundary edges in the half- and free-spaces by attempting to deliberately omit them in each case. We considered four test setups as follows: (1a) no virtual vertices for a structure in Fig. 2(a), (1b) deliberately omitting the boundary edges in Fig. 2(b), (2a) inserting the virtual vertices in Fig. 2(a), and (2b) a structure as in Fig. 2(b) in free-space as a reference.
The starting and ending points of a boundary edge are
v1 and v2, and the center point of the boundary edge is vc(Fig. 1). The virtual vertex associated with the boundary edge is located at a distance dfrom the center point vc. When the angle θvis zero, the position of the virtual vertex is vd0 as shown in Fig. 1. The distance dcan be represented by the multiplication of a length Le=| v1？ v2| of the boundary edge and a normalized distance eb= d/ Lewhich has a range of 10？7< eb≤10？1 . Using the reference point vd0and the vertex angle θv, a position vdof a virtual vertex placed at a specific angle can be generated as shown in Fig. 2(c).
The normalized RCS pattern (line with dots) for the test setup (2a) with virtual vertices agrees well with the reference setup (2b), as shown in Fig. 3. However, the normalized RCS pattern (line with diamonds) for the test setup (1a) without virtual vertices does not agree well with the result (line with circles) of the test-setup (2b) for the vv-polarized backscatter, but it agrees with the test setup (1b) that is distorted by deliberately omitting the boundary edge (line with squares).
In all four test conditions, insertion of the virtual vertices affects the RCS at vertical polarization (vvpol.), while horizontal polarization (hh-pol.) is not affected, so that the four lines are placed on top of each other, as shown in Fig. 3. The current sources vertically passing through the boundary edges are relatively agitated by the ground, so the vv-polarized RCS shows significant errors without the addition of the virtual vertices in this calculation.
Fig. 4 shows the polarimetric responses of the test setup (2a) with variation of
θvfrom 0° to 180°. These scanned data along with the angular position of virtual vertex as a function of θvcan be used to analyze their angular effect by using the reference data, which are the result of the test setup (2b) in free-space. The numbers of interior edges used to solve this scattering problem are 140 and 273 edges, respectively. These scanned data were expressed at 2.5° intervals and fully computed 5329 times.
We analyzed the angular effect of the virtual vertices by computing the differences of the RCSs between the two test setups (2a) and (2b) at various angular positions for vv- and hh-polarizations, as shown in Fig. 5. Both test conditions are equivalent, so the test setup (2b) is considered as a reference to examine the computational accuracy of the test setup (2a), which includes the virtual vertices. In the case of vv-polarization, the difference is maximized when
θrapproaches to 0° or 180° because of the inaccuracy at null-points, where the backscatter is seriously insensitive at these regions, such as in the vicinity of 0°, 60°, 120° and 180°, as shown in Fig. 5(a).
θr=90°, almost no difference exists between the two test setups. The difference is also minimized when the vertex angle θvapproaches 0° or 180°, which indicates that the optimum position of the virtual vertex is on the ground plane. On the other hand, at hh-polarization, the difference is lower than 0.05dB, except at the vicinity of θr=0° or 180°, as shown in Fig. 5(b).
Fig. 6(a) illustrates the fact that the virtual vertices at
θv=0° and 180° have a minimized difference of less than about 0.7 dB at all inclination angles θrof the conducting plate. In particular, it demonstrates optimum performance even at the inclination angle of θr=90°. Therefore, insertion of the virtual vertices is valid even when the surface of a test object placed on a ground plane or their basis vectors are normal to the ground plane. Fig. 6(a) also shows that the difference as a function of θvis symmetric regardless of the inclination angle of the test object. In other words, a vertical component of the current source passing through the problematic boundary edge contributes to the MoM process. The synthesized vector to depict them is also sensitive to changes in the angular position of the virtual vertex. Therefore, the magnitude of the vertical component of the synthesized vector is deterministic in this computational process. In addition, Fig. 6(b) shows that the θr-cut and the difference is also minimized at θv=0° and 180°, less than about 0.6dB in the range of 5°≤ θr≤175°. Two peaks located at θr=65° and 120° are related to the inaccurate results at the null-points, as mentioned before. Lastly, a sudden change or singularity caused by an abnormal formation of the virtual vertex is not observed at all angular positions, as shown in Figs. 5 and 6.
In addition, this proposed method can be compared with the existing method for the half-space scattering problem. This performance is also summarized as shown in Table 2. In particular, when a metal hemisphere on an infinite ground plane was used as a test target, it consists of two kinds of hemispheres, with and without a bottom side in contact with the interface of the halfspace . Extraction of the singularity caused by the bottom side cells also requires an additional sub-function in the MoM process. This may affect the delay, thereby increasing the processing time and poor accuracy.
We investigated the angular effect of the virtual vertices inserted to treat the boundary edges on an infinite conducting surface in this study. A vertical component of the synthesized vector that expresses the current source passing through the problematic boundary edge was identified as contributing to the MoM process for halfspace scattering. Therefore, the angular position of a virtual vertex should be selected to be maximized as a vertical component of the synthesized vector. The optimum angular position of the virtual vertices might lie on the ground plane,
i.e., θv=0° or 180°, regardless of the inclination angle of the triangle cell associated with the problematic boundary edge. This virtual vertex technique also improves the accuracy of the RCS computation of a half-space scattering problem for all cases, regardless of the angle of θr, even when the angle between θvand θris 90°. In addition, the technique effectively manages the number of interior edges by the reduction of physical redundancy of triangular cells on ground surface.
Finally, this proposed technique will contribute to increased accuracy of the numerical model for analyzing the scattering property of scattering particles above the ground surface in the field of microwave remote sensing.
[Fig. 1.] Geometry of the boundary edge laid on an infinite conducting surface and arbitrarily positioned virtual vertex (vd or vd0 on z=0).
[Fig. 2.] Test setups with an inclined conducting plate with an inclination angle θr.
[Fig. 3.] Scattering property of conducting plates with each test setup: Note that test setup (2a) was computed at reference position, vd0.
[Fig. 4.] Scattering property of a conducting plate at various angles with 0°≤θv≤180° and 0°≤θr≤180° (using test setup (2a)).
[Fig. 5.] Differences between the test setup (2a) with virtual vertices and the test setup (2b) as a reference.
[Fig. 6.] Detail views of the angular effect of virtual vertices.
[Table 1.] Angular effect of the virtual vertex.
[Table 2.] Comparison results of the proposed virtual vertex technique using a metal hemisphere on ground surface.